Monday, June 28, 2010

Thoughts/Reflections on US Social Forum


Over 10,000 people and organizations from around the country and world, including the Coalition for Economic Justice's Buffalo Delegation, marched together down the streets of Detroit as the 2010 US Social Forum began last Tuesday. Amidst the inspiring and eclectic atmosphere of marching bands, workers' rights groups, giant polar bears, and giant puppets of social justice leaders like Mother Jones, a unifying thread began to emerge: we are here, we are strong, and we're not going away.

Perhaps no US city could be a more fitting location for a social forum than Detroit. A phrase we heard repeatedly from Detroit-based organizers was "Detroit is what the rest of the US has to look forward to." A city of firsts - the first auto plant, the first inner-city highway, the first shopping mall and subsequent major suburban population shift, Detroit now describes itself as the first city truly grappling with developing a subsistence economy in a post-Industrial landscape. To their credit, a major food-security movement is developing in the vacant and abandoned city lots, and programs like Detroit Summer, a Boggs Center project, are inspiring and engaging youth in transformational work to change lives and shape the direction of their city.

However, as most of us in the Buffalo Delegation were thinking, Detroit holds many important lessons for our city. The scale of devastation is almost mind-boggling. You have a major downtown center with hardly anyone on the streets, high-rise buildings unoccupied in various states of decay, and entire city blocks vacant in some areas as far as the eye can see. There are plans among city officials of closing off and shutting down large parts of the city due to sparse population. Indeed, the visit to Detroit reminded us at CEJ of the incredible importance of fighting for good jobs and sustainable economic development. If we don't succeed, then the folks from the Motor City might be right, Detroit would be what we have to look forward to.

Beyond Detroit, the rest of the US Social Forum was much less grim, in fact it was awe-inspiring and at times, brilliant. The scene - Appalachian mountain justice activists sitting next to labor organizers from Chicago, Pakistani working women's representatives in conversation with debt cancellation advocates from Columbia and Belgium - people from all forms of work sharing lessons, visions, and growing the kind of solidarity necessary for collective liberation. What really hit home for me through all of this was the clarity with which I was able to see that our struggles are connected. We truly struggle together to advance justice for all. While we face and challenge oppression in different ways, we are fighting the same fight. Therefore my fight is yours, and your fight is mine.

Coming back to Buffalo, I know that this lesson applies here. The question becomes this, "What are the ways in which we can effectively support one another?" Perhaps a Buffalo Social Forum is necessary to draw out those connections... ? I am reminded of the last workshop I attended at the social forum, entitled Establishing Mutual Aid Models with The Rock Dove Collective. A group of women from Brooklyn, NY have established a network of health care service providers for low income and marginalized people based on the economic model of mutually beneficial trades of labor. Members assess their own situations in determining both what they need, and what they can give. Through the existence of the network community members are able to access forms of health care they would normally be unable to afford, and everyone is satisfied with the trade. It seems that mutual aid in terms of solidarity and support is an idea for progressive communities in Buffalo to pay attention to. The Rock Dove Collective show us that our needs, and our abilities to give often overlap, and through bridging those connections we move a little closer to collective liberation.

Monday, June 21, 2010

CEJ Sets Sail for Detroit and US Social Forum

The long-awaited 2010 US Social Forum kicks off in Detroit, Michigan today, and CEJ will be there in solidarity with organizers and movements from across the country and around the world! As you can tell, we are all very excited about this special event, and glad that folks from Buffalo can take part!

What is the US Social Forum, you may ask? The USSF is a 5 day process where tens of thousands of people and organizations come together to affirm and articulate values and strategies of a growing and vibrant movement for justice in the United States. It is a space for building people's solutions to the crises that are effecting us all.

With help from our friends at Buffalo Car Share, our caravan shipped off bright and early from the Lafayette Avenue Presbyterian Church. We know there will be lots to share when we come back, and we will look forward to doing so.

IDA Rally



TAXPAYERS SAY ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!

This past Friday (6/18), we made a wake-up call to Senators William Stachowski and Antoine Thompson, telling them that it is time to fix NYS's broken economic development plans, create quality jobs, and put NY on the road to recovery.

Fellow concerned taxpayers joined us as we carried out a skit showing how Industrial Development Agencies use taxpayers like ATM machines - withdrawing large amounts of cash! The performance gave those in attendance a view into what an IDA board meeting might look like. Although, in real life it's not nearly as comical.

IDAs are the main engine for economic development throughout NYS. They award tax exemptions and tax-free bond financing to businesses in return for job creation and retention. However, a new audit released on May 7, 2010 by NYS Comptroller DiNapoli shows that while spending by IDAs increased, job creation decreased. The Comptroller's report, based on 2008 data, shows net tax exemptions grew 9% over the previous year to $645 million, but job creation decreased nearly 14%.

With the economic crisis we are currently facing, we can no longer afford to give away $645 million in net tax exemptions. And we certainly cannot keep letting IDAs and corporations use taxpayers like their own personal ATMs.

Check out the full script of the skit below!

Rally to Sound the Alarm for Good Jobs
By Andy Reynolds


Location: 237 Main Street
Date: 6.18.10
Time: 12:00 PM

An IDA Board Meeting to Approve Tax Break for Corporation in 1 Act:

Setting: IDA Board Meeting

Designated “Cast”:
IDA Board President: Andy Reynolds
Corporation: Jim Anderson
ATM (Taxpayer) Machine: Rachel Wilson
Activist: Terrence Robinson

Act 1: The Board Meeting (IDA Board President stands behind table; Corporate CEO stands in front of table; and ATM Machine stands to the side of the table)

IDA: “The Everyone’s Cash Industrial Development Agency has one order of business: To give away taxpayer dollars to corporations. With New York State Government soundly asleep, we can do whatever we want with the public’s money.

You look like a fine outstanding business and we’re desperate to make deals. The more deals we make, and the bigger they are, the more money we make here at the IDA. So, The Everyone’s Cash IDA board has decided to give you a million dollars for every job you create.”

Corporation: “We were going to build the project without taxpayer subsidies, but since you are offering, we will take your money.”

IDA: “Well, it isn’t our money, so what do we care. We were created as a public benefit corporation to help companies save or create good paying jobs. We prefer instead to give corporations, and sometimes even amusement parks, handouts and look the other way when they create low paying jobs or don’t create any jobs at all.

It’s much easier for everyone. I mean, we can’t even find the filing cabinet we place billing information in to make sure corporations are paying their taxes on time. Speaking of paying taxes, how long would you like to avoid having to pay your ‘fair share’.” (IDA says mockingly, using finger quotes, when saying ‘fair share’).

Corporation: “Let’s start with 15 years. We can always ask for another 15 year extension when that time is up or we might just move to another suburb before we have to start paying taxes. I’m sure the Amherst IDA would be happy to give us a huge tax-break.

IDA: “You are under no obligations here. You can take this money and run. We both know that a lot of other corporations have already done the same. By the way, we can give you the public funding to build an office park way out in the middle of nowhere. You know the saying: If you build it . . . sprawl will come.”

“Now that we both understand how this agreement works, why don’t you head over to the taxpayer ATM and take as much money as you want?” How many jobs did you say you would create?”

Corporation: “I didn’t, but we can pretend I did.”

Both IDA and Corporation laugh as corporation takes cash from ATM.

Activist:

The 115 IDAs across NYS might not have ATMs in their lobbies, but the skit you just witnessed isn’t too far a cry from what happens regularly here in Erie County and across NYS.

Industrial Development Agencies are one of NY’s primary engines for job creation and economic development. They are authorized by the state to provide financial assistance to “advance the job opportunities, health, general prosperity, and economic welfare of the people of the state of NY.” These quasi-governmental agencies grant projects exemptions from state and local taxes and issue tax exempt bonds.

In a time of great economic uncertainty for many individuals and families across NYS, including here in Buffalo, IDAs are spending more of our taxpayer dollars, and doing less for our communities.


IDAs having been failing us for too long! IDAs are now giving away $645 million in net tax exemptions each year. We’re facing the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression. We can no longer afford to give away the candy store. $645 million is not an insignificant amount of money. Combine that figure with the half a billion dollars we throw away each year through the Empire Zone program and the money starts to add up.

If ever there was a time for meaningful reform it is now. But, The State Legislative session is slated to end next week and so called elected leaders haven’t even passed a budget.

Instead of talking about how many teachers we need to layoff, or what social services we need to slash, why don’t our elected leaders in the Assembly, the Senate, and the Governor’s office start making the ‘tough choices’ they keep saying need to be made.

The NYS Assembly has consistently acted in support of IDA reform, but for reform efforts to move forward the Senate needs to wake up and realize it’s time to work with the Assembly to craft a winning bill.

We’ll be delivering our wake up call to WNY majority Senators Stachowski and Thompson today, asking them to work with the Assembly and Senate Leadership to fix our broken economic development system and put folks to work in quality jobs.

IDAs are plagued by poor performance and ill-equipped to aid in our economic recovery. It’s time to Get our Money’s Worth.

Wednesday, June 2, 2010

Report on Bass Pro Shops Shows Company Often Fails to Live Up To Its Promises



The Buffalo-based Public Accountability Initiative (PAI) has released a new report on Bass Pro's record of taxpayer-subsidized growth. The report shows that the company frequently fails to live up to its promises as an economic development anchor -- promises which were used to justify major public subsidies.


The report, titled "Fishing for Taxpayer Cash: Bass Pro's Record of Big-League Subsidies, Failed Promises, and the Consequences for Cities Across America," was co-authored by Andrew Stecker and Kevin Connor, both of PAI. It is available here: http://www.scribd.com/doc/32370256/Fishing-for-Taxpayer-Cash.


Among the findings: a Bass Pro-anchored mall in Cincinnati is 65% vacant and has been described as "post-apocalyptic" by visitors; one in Mesa, Arizona helped prompt a statewide ban on retail subsidies; and a shopping plaza in the shadow of a Bass Pro in Council Bluffs, IA was recently described by a local politician as an empty "shell of a building." Bass Pro-anchored projects have won over $500 million in taxpayer subsidies, despite the retailer's frequent failure to deliver on its promises of generating development and growth.


The report is intended to inform the choices of cities like Buffalo, which are considering subsidizing Bass Pro stores in order to generate economic growth, and is being distributed to cities across the country.

The Buffalo News reported on the report in June 2nd's paper. You can see that article here: http://www.buffalonews.com/2010/06/02/1068505/report-doubts-bass-pro-on-tax.htm